Over Fifty Members of Congress Call for Special Counsel Investigation into NSA Domestic Surveillance
Members, led by Rep. Lofgren, Renew Call for Special Counsel in Light of New Information
Media Contact: Kyra Jennings, 202.225.3072, kyra.jennings@mail.house.gov
Below is the text of the letter:
May 11, 2006
The President
The White House
Washington, D.C. 20500
Recent reports state that the NSA’s domestic surveillance of Americans is much more expansive than you previously stated. You said that the NSA surveillance program only targets international communications between Americans and suspected members of al Qaeda. Now we learn the NSA routinely collects the call records of tens of millions of Americans from telecommunications companies collectively serving more than 200 million Americans. These reports also suggest that the NSA has equipment on AT&T’s network to monitor all Internet data passing over it. If true, these reports are truly shocking. We urge you once again to direct the appointment of a Special Counsel fully empowered to investigate the NSA’s domestic surveillance programs and report its findings to Congress.
It is time the American public and the Congress had more than press reports to establish the facts about NSA’s domestic surveillance programs. Several Members of Congress wrote to you nearly three months ago asking for the appointment of a Special Counsel to investigate the NSA’s surveillance of Americans. We still have not received your response.
Every practical avenue for investigation has been stymied based on the feeblest of excuses. When Members of Congress wrote to the Inspector Generals of the Justice and Defense Departments, they refused to investigate. The Justice Department handed the matter to its Office of Professional Responsibility for an investigation of professional legal misconduct, and then denied security clearances to its own investigators. The Defense Department handed the matter to NSA’s Inspector General, who never responded and who approved the eavesdropping at issue. The Government Accountability Office refused to investigate, anticipating you would block access to records by designating them foreign intelligence or counterintelligence materials. While the House and Senate Judiciary Committees have held hearings, they have not issued a single subpoena for witnesses or documentary evidence. Instead of investigation, all that emerges is a pattern of resisting investigation into the facts that Congress and the public deserve.
Given the Attorney General’s authorization of domestic eavesdropping by the NSA and his highly public defense of it, a Special Counsel is needed to avoid any conflict of interest in investigating the NSA programs. The Attorney General’s recent testimony in the House Judiciary Committee suggests he has much to hide. The Attorney General acknowledged under oath that the Deputy Attorney General initially disapproved of an NSA eavesdropping program separate from the warrantless eavesdropping you described on international communications with al Qaeda members. But the Attorney General refused to tell the House Judiciary Committee anything about that separate NSA eavesdropping program. If the news reports cited above are true, the Attorney General also provided highly misleading testimony when asked whether the NSA was eavesdropping on calls entirely within the United States.
Without a complete and impartial investigation of the facts, Members of Congress are robbed of their Article I oversight responsibilities under the Constitution. The American public is robbed of its ability to hold Article II officials accountable for their conduct. While we appreciate the need to safeguard sensitive classified information, existing legal protections for handling of classified information would allow an investigation to proceed without compromising national security.
Mr. President, both our Constitutional duties and yours are to protect the security of the nation from terrorist threats and to protect and uphold the laws of our nation. The NSA’s domestic eavesdropping programs may fail in both. Without a thorough investigation into the facts, we can simply never know. We urge you once again to direct the appointment of a Special Counsel fully empowered to investigate the NSA’s domestic eavesdropping programs and report its findings to Congress.
Sincerely,
Zoe Lofgren
Gary Ackerman
Joe Baca
Brian Baird
Howard Berman
Rick Boucher
Robert Brady
Sherrod Brown
Julia Carson
Lois Capps
William Clay
John Conyers
Susan Davis
Peter DeFazio
William DeLahunt
Rosa DeLauro
John Dingell
Lloyd Doggett
Eliot Engel
Sam Farr
Ra"l M. Grijalva
Maurice Hinchey
Rush Holt
Mike Honda
Jay Inslee
Jim Langevin
Tom Lantos
Barbara Lee
John Lewis
Stephen Lynch
Carolyn Maloney
Doris Matsui
Marty Meehan
Betty McCollum
Jim McGovern
Jerrold Nadler
Ed Pastor
Collin Peterson
David Price
John Salazar
Linda Sanchez
Loretta Sanchez
Adam Smith
Hilda Solis
Pete Stark
Bart Stupak
Ellen Tauscher
Bennie Thompson
Mike Thompson
Mark Udall
Peter Visclosky
Debbie Wasserman Schultz
Maxine Waters
Dianne Watson
Robert Wexler
